It certainly seemed by the comments
But I think it's often misinterpreted as antagonistic, when it isn't. Not to say I'm not frequently antagonistic... or that that post isn't somewhat antagonistic. That's not the point of the post, though.
I hope that people who have engaged me in honest discussions know that I will concede the point when I'm wrong. I'm not trying to "win" an argument. I'm trying to understand where people are coming from. I find that often it is useful to make a challenging statement like that so that people can dispel the extreme interpretation of what they are expressing. I feel like it is an honest thing to do on my part, but maybe it isn't taken that way. Maybe people take is as though I'm trying to take a sly jab at people by asking a question like that, and that I'm waiting for a predictable response so that I can pounce and then beat my chest about how smart I am. I hope that people, like BigB, who I've spent dozens and dozens of hours with in person and years on jazzfans, know that I'm not trying to do that to them when I engage in a discussion with them.
I do.He does that sometimes...
But I think it's often misinterpreted as antagonistic, when it isn't. Not to say I'm not frequently antagonistic... or that that post isn't somewhat antagonistic. That's not the point of the post, though.
I hope that people who have engaged me in honest discussions know that I will concede the point when I'm wrong. I'm not trying to "win" an argument. I'm trying to understand where people are coming from. I find that often it is useful to make a challenging statement like that so that people can dispel the extreme interpretation of what they are expressing. I feel like it is an honest thing to do on my part, but maybe it isn't taken that way. Maybe people take is as though I'm trying to take a sly jab at people by asking a question like that, and that I'm waiting for a predictable response so that I can pounce and then beat my chest about how smart I am. I hope that people, like BigB, who I've spent dozens and dozens of hours with in person and years on jazzfans, know that I'm not trying to do that to them when I engage in a discussion with them.