7StraightIsGreat
Well-Known Member
It's infinitely harder to take losses that happen because you have no offense than it is to lose in a shootout, that's for sure. In fact, I think that's one of the best cases against Mendenhall. The main knock seems to be that they don't beat teams they aren't supposed to beat under him and struggle in close games regardless, but secondary to that to me is that BYU has struggled to be entertaining and to live up to the pass happy reputation that made them who they are. It's hard having a guy that doesn't specialize in offense being the head coach at BYU.
Agree to an extent but I don't think you need to see BYU return to the pass happy days with an offensive minded coach to make fans happy. I'm guessing BYU fans would be just fine with winning scores like 17-to-3 against teams like Texas, Utah, Notre Dame, etc. Fans just want to watch good football, and whatever BYU has going on offensively right now is certainly not good. The flip side of that is, it's awfully hard to hold teams like Texas to 3 points, even with a good defense. Yes, you need some offense but without an O-line, you can't even get started. Colton nailed it: Taysom probably isn't that bad, but how can you tell with the amount of pressure he's facing?
Going forward, BYU's 2013 season (and maybe Bronco's job) will be defined by whether or not the O-line can get better on the fly. The team sports a great front 7 on Defense, at the very least a decent QB, and some amazing skill players on offense (Jamal and Hoffman). However, it's hard to envision BYU with a winning record unless that O-line pulls it together.