I agree with you.
I think we all get to make our own decisions about the relationships we enter. This very fantastic notion One Brow is expressing about how a transgender female is a female and should be able to simply exist as a female starts to fall apart in the context of a romantic relationship*. A transgender female looking for a relationship with a cisgender male should filter their dating pool for cisgender males interested in the actual relationship they will be entering.
So, a cisgender woman with vaginal scars that make vaginal sex off-limits needs to put this information on a dating site, so all men who might go out with her will know ahead of time the actual relationship they will be entering? Does that also apply to men who have penile deformities? If you don't think either of those situations should apply, why is it different for transgender people?
I also agree that there are very real safety concerns in hiding transgender status from cisgender males. That's not victim blaming in my opinion, that's reality facing transgender females when dealing with potentially violent men. Ask cisgender females about dating. It's ****ing scary for them a lot of the time. They don't know when they might be assaulted and far far too many of them are. That's the reality of dealing with cisgender males. Too many of them are ****ing neanderthals. Don't encourage transgender females to see if the cisgender male "clocks" them. That's a game of life and death that lies squarely on the shoulders of our culture and the way cisgender males are socially expected to behave.
Have you considered the other side of this scary situation? The men who, seeing that a transgender person is on a dating site, will actually set a trap for these women, and the women possibly getting battered by more than one person? If that happens, is the transgender woman at fault for putting that they are transgender on a dating site, making herself a target?
Good relationships are built on honesty and trust.
Honesty and trust is something you build, not take for granted.
