Stars Off the Schneid

Discussion in 'Utah Jazz' started by homeytennis, Jan 7, 2020.

  1. Handlogten's Heros

    Handlogten's Heros Well-Known Member 2019 Award Winner

    21,928
    11,551
    433
    Jun 13, 2014
    I think the tools are intriguing... I think I’m not looking for awesome defensively... just more effective than Niang and I think he’d give us that.

    The thing that intrigued me on him in the preseason is he stood up Giannis a couple times on defense. That power wing type is going to be something we need in the playoffs. Now that we are out of options on the trade market that’s something I’d like to see us start prepping for.
     
  2. Handlogten's Heros

    Handlogten's Heros Well-Known Member 2019 Award Winner

    21,928
    11,551
    433
    Jun 13, 2014
    I think we are too rigid sometimes... plan was to let him work in the g league all year regardless of performance... I think you need to get guys out to test them a bit.
     
  3. homeytennis

    homeytennis Well-Known Member

    6,318
    923
    198
    May 26, 2010
    I think the Jazz are wondering which JB they will get. The Superman of last night who was a human wrecking ball or the JB that had nine turnovers in a game.
     
  4. idiot

    idiot Well-Known Member

    1,363
    307
    133
    Jun 30, 2010
    Not saying that it's impossible that you're right; I like Brantley's tools too. But Niang had better D-rating with Stars than Brantley has, despite Niang's Stars teams being far worse at defense overall than Brantley's is this year.

    I just think Jazz fans (including many on this board) have had a tendency to over-rate Brantley's likely impact this year based on his tools/potential, and haven't looked closely enough at his actual play.
     
  5. Handlogten's Heros

    Handlogten's Heros Well-Known Member 2019 Award Winner

    21,928
    11,551
    433
    Jun 13, 2014
    Don't read too much into defensive rating... defense is too noisy to use catch all type measures. Kanter has the same defensive rating as Rudy does this year... just an example.

    I think we do over-rate the unknown... I just think his length and activity are better than Georges defensive IQ. I guess I'd just like to see... let's give it a try for 5 games.
     
  6. idiot

    idiot Well-Known Member

    1,363
    307
    133
    Jun 30, 2010
    Generally, I agree that d-rating is a poor measure. In particular, it is too team-dependent. Good defensive teams end up giving poor defenders good ratings, and poor defensive teams end up giving good defenders poor ratings. The measure is also too position-dependent (favors bigs over smalls).

    But none of this typical bias works to justify Brantley here. Niang and Brantley play basically the same position. Brantley belongs to a much better defensive team with the Stars than Niang ever did, yet his defensive rating is both absolutely worse than Niang's was and relatively worse (Niang's was always near team-best, Brantley is near team-worst).

    Again, it's not impossible that despite this all, Brantley could perform better for the Jazz defensively than Niang has. But I don't think the odds are on his side (at least not yet, until he's developed a little more). I think the expectation that "anyone has to be better than Niang" is both understandable and wrong.
     
  7. homeytennis

    homeytennis Well-Known Member

    6,318
    923
    198
    May 26, 2010
    Actually the Stars are really good defensively when they have their top players there this year.
     
  8. homeytennis

    homeytennis Well-Known Member

    6,318
    923
    198
    May 26, 2010
    A guy that played for Texas vs the Stars last night, Moises Brown, appeared for the Blazers tonight vs the Pels. He is a rookie with one year at UCLA.
     
  9. homeytennis

    homeytennis Well-Known Member

    6,318
    923
    198
    May 26, 2010
    Stars lost by a lot to the Lakers JVs and the Stars played with 8 players. JWF and Brantley were the only players with Jazz ties to play for the Stars. No NWG, Willie Reed, Oni, Tucker, Morgan, Collinsworth, Pryor or Paul White. Benlevi had 29, Brantley 25 and Bluiett with 20 for the Stars. Haas had 15 rebounds and Mike Scott had 7 assists. JWF shot a lot and didn't make a lot. The Stars were plucky and cut it to 6 with about 4 minutes left but were out of gas. Too much David Stockton and Pierre Jackson for the Lakers. Two former Jazz alums did the Stars in.
     
  10. homeytennis

    homeytennis Well-Known Member

    6,318
    923
    198
    May 26, 2010
    From the Stars Facebook page:
    Fun facts about last night:
    ✅ Malik Benlevi secured a game-high and with 29 points (5 rebounds, 2 assists)
    ✅ Jarrell Brantley posted his 5ᴛʜ consecutive 20-ᴘᴏɪɴᴛ game (25 points, 6 rebounds, 4 assists)
    ✅ Isaac Haas grabbed a career high 15 rebounds
     
  11. Catchall

    Catchall Well-Known Member 2019 Prediction Contest Winner

    21,856
    3,777
    263
    May 27, 2010
     
    homeytennis likes this.

Share This Page