Right, and in that situation you may find yourself genuinely attracted to someone you don't find particularly attractive in a purely physical sense. Same with One Brow saying he was more attracted to the girls in the Chess Club. He didn't have to approach these girls in a bar or something, he interacted with them in the Chess Club and became attracted based on those interactions. The notion that you're gonna find people attractive based on your ability to get "hot" women doesn't always apply.
I'm not trying to say it does. I am just saying there is something that makes you want to get to notice that woman. It could be the combination of glasses and a book, a physical trait such as long legs, or that girl in class that always gets As...
I like the mix of pale skin and dark hair.