There are a number of posts I wanted to respond to, but there have been some consistent themes, so I will just address this in bulk:
There's the argument of Rudy checking out and/or demanding touches. The reason I was originally going to bring up AK is because I could see this being used as a parallel, though I would vehemently reject this. When AK was complaining about touches, we had an elite offense and Deron, Boozer, and Okur and are significantly much better offensively than him. When he was complaining about touches, it was for his own personal gain because we were winning and what we needed from him were all the other things. We already had a good offense. When Rudy is complaining about touches, my own bias fundamentally believes that this is not simply about Rudy "getting his" but because our offense was ****. Like, despite all our talent, we were nearly historically bad in how inefficient we could be for very, very long stretches. When Rudy was complaining about touches, I see this more than something that was only hurting Rudy, but more that it was actually costing us as a team. We were missing Rudy right under the basket for the most efficient shot possible. The guy who broke the dunk record last year. We replaced that with a lot of floaters, contested shots, force-ups, and hero ball. This wasn't about Rudy wanting to score 20 per night (on the flip side, it was about everyone else wanting to score 20 per night!). AK was complaining about touches in an offense that was working. Gobert is complaining about not being fed the ball for easy baskets in an offense that is sucking serious *** and dropping many games in the most unacceptable fashions.
Then there's the effort part the past couple months. I'm not one to make excuses. But when we put this in context, we've been asking for, and have gotten accustomed to, ungodly defensive performances from Rudy. That's the bar. He wasn't consistently providing that the past couple months. That's obvious. But he wasn't terrible. He just wasn't ungodly. The most important thing is that, despite not giving the ungodly effort, he still gave significantly more effort defensively than anyone on the team! But this became magnified as he wasn't able to clean up everyone else's mess as efficiently as we had just come to expect. So when we say he didn't give effort, we're only comparing him against himself. Donovan started the season with really good defensive effort. For the rest of the season, his defensive effort was dog ****. We don't call him on this because we aren't accustomed to him performing that well, as we are for Rudy.